If you’ve read any of my other posts here, or even just by the description of this blog (feminist mama), you can imagine that I am not generally a big fan of the Disney Princess’s. I’m most especially not a fan of the idea of the helpless but pretty heroine, reclining gracefully on a pink pillow until her Prince Charming can conquer the scary dragon and save the day with his oh-so-wonderful kiss. (I’m looking at you, Sleeping Beauty!)
So it’s with some trepidation that I tell you that I’m currently in the throes of All Things Princess, with an adorable Princess-Obsessed dictator running around in sparkly high heels and Cinderella dresses.
Trepidation? No, that’s not even really true. The truth is that I am having a BLAST with it. I feel pretty good about the fact that I’ve given my daughter a female-positive background to play out these fairy stories against. I feel joy when she switches in a beat from being Cinderella to being “Super Bella, saving people from mud!”
I have come a long way in my thoughts on princesses, from hoping against hope I’d be able to avoid the issue entirely to looking at it more critically and talking to lots and lots of other moms about it. I realized that one of the primary things which bugs me about the Disney princesses specifically is the heavy-duty marketing aimed at toddlers, the pervasive presence of those damsels in distress, and the way the people in our society reinforce those images again and again and again. The other thing I don’t like is the false body-images presented, but honestly that is less of an issue for me… right now.
It came crashing down on me that I would not be able to avoid the issue entirely when anytime Bella saw a princess, anywhere, she’d ask me the name of the princess. At first I would try to distract her from it, or say I didn’t know, but finally I just gave up and gave her the information she wanted. I thought a few times about telling her that I didn’t like those princesses and why, but that felt *wrong.* She is not old enough to understand my reasons, but she is old enough to feel badly that mama doesn’t like what she likes.
I realized quite quickly that she was getting about 90% of her Princess exposure from her preschool teacher. A woman whom I adore and think is, in most ways, lovely. But she also happens to be an *excellent* Disney marketer, whether she knows it or not, providing her classroom with things like Disney princess tents, laptops, tea sets, the princess dolls themselves, and one night when Bella told me she’d mixed a potion to “take away her voice,” I knew she’d been telling them princess stories. Even though they were not (are not) listed on the class syllabus.
At the time I found myself trying to decide what to do. Unfortunately my options for preschool here are pretty limited, and I love this school, love 95% of the things about it, and my daughter adores it. So I decided to try to take the negatives in stride. Besides, she’d be exposed sooner or later, right? The Disney Divas are *unavoidable.*
And so it goes. It has grown from there. Thus far I have stood by my original resolve to take it one step at a time and not, for now, let her see the movies. For Christmas, Santa brought her a Cinderella dress, an Ariel bath doll, and “Ariel’s Beginning,” a princess movie without a prince that I thought might be mild enough to capture her imagination. Mild? Ummmm, no. The mermaid mom gets crushed by a pirate ship in the opening scene, after which the poor mermaid dad is just angry forever and I’m not sure I can blame him. Bella was terrified of the cackling, mean mermaid assistant and I wound up forwarding through most of the movie. So when I tell her truthfully that the princess movies she asks about are too scary for her, she believes me. Sleeping Beauty would give her nightmares for ages! Ursula in The Little Mermaid would terrify her. She is just a sensitive little soul.
One of the other things I got her for Christmas was a set of Snow White figurines. She was having such a hard time sharing the princess figures at school that I figured if she had some at home, maybe it would be easier. (No such luck.) So we got a set with Snow White, the prince, the evil queen, the old lady with the apple, and the seven dwarves. It’s really a lovely little set, I have to say, with beautiful details on the figures. I didn’t give her the evil queen and old lady at first thinking they might be too scary, but as she has gotten more drawn to good/evil battles I got them out for her… and she has her fairy friends bewitch them so that they can be nice.
She has such a good heart.
I’m going on and on and on, and I really could talk about this for days, and probably will if I ever get a single quiet moment in the house again. (B. is out with her Daddy right now… blessed quiet!) But I had to post something because I posted a picture of her in her Cinderella dress on my facebook, and someone replied “I thought you weren’t going to let her do the princess thing!” That is actually not what I said, ever. I said I’d hold off on it for as long as I could, and I have. I said that I don’t want to show her the movies, and I don’t. I said that many aspects of the Disney empire bother me, and they do. But ultimately I’m a mom who loves sparkles and dresses and happy endings myself, so it is no mystery that my daughter would be the same way.
Right now her favorite color is blue. Cross your fingers that it stays that way!
Posted: February 21st, 2010 under Uncategorized - No Comments.
Tags: feminism, gender, princess, say yes